Should a VC fund do FX hedging?

Get access to more articles on reporting, accounting, tax and compliance by Signing Up.

DISCLAIMER: The information provided  here does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal or financial advice; instead, all information & content are for general informational purposes only. 

Introduction

Many venture capital (VC) teams today operate internationally, making investments in various currencies. They anticipate successful exits from their companies, which would result in significant proceeds. However, it's often uncertain how much they will receive and in which currency. This raises an important question for General Partners (GPs) at VC funds: Should you hedge your FX exposure?

In this article, we explore the merits and considerations of FX hedging for VC funds.

Understanding FX Risk in Venture Capital

FX risk, or currency risk, arises from fluctuations in exchange rates between the currency in which an investment is denominated and the fund’s reporting currency. For VC funds with a global portfolio, these fluctuations can significantly impact the reported value of foreign assets and the returns on those investments.

The FX effect materializes when you sell an investment in one currency but need to distribute the proceeds in another. For instance, if a fund distributes proceeds to its investors in EUR and makes an investment in the US that is expected to sell for USD, eventually, you will need to convert those USD proceeds into EUR for distribution to LPs. Anticipating and managing this exchange is the essence of FX hedging.

The Case for FX Hedging

1. Protecting Returns: FX volatility can significantly diminish the real returns of an otherwise successful investment. By hedging against currency fluctuations, a fund can ensure that the returns more accurately reflect the true performance of the investment, rather than being a byproduct of market volatility.

2. Financial Stability: Frequent currency value fluctuations can create considerable instability in a fund’s performance. Hedging strategies serve to stabilise results, offering more predictable outcomes for investors and limited partners alike.

3. Competitive Advantage: The venture capital market is intensely competitive. Limited Partners (LPs) seek to invest in teams that not only excel in investments but also operations and financial strategy. Demonstrating robust risk management that includes FX risk considerations can distinguish a fund. It indicates a well-rounded and strategic financial management, appealing to discerning investors.

The Case against FX Hedging

1. Cost Implications: Hedging comes at a price. The costs associated with setting up hedging contracts can be significant and must be balanced against the potential benefits of reducing FX risk.

2. Potential for Missed Gains: Hedging guards against losses but also limits potential gains. If a fund’s base currency depreciates against foreign currencies, a hedged fund misses out on these potential benefits.

3. Complexity: Implementing a successful hedging strategy demands expertise and adds a layer of complexity to fund management. This can be particularly challenging for smaller funds, where the management resources are already stretched thin.

General Considerations for FX Hedging in Venture Capital

1. Strategic Selection: Not every currency exposure might necessitate hedging. It’s crucial for a fund to identify which currency risks could meaningfully impact the fund’s financial stability. This strategic selection helps in focusing resources where they are most needed and avoids unnecessary hedging expenses.

2. Instrument Choice: The selection of hedging instruments is paramount. Derivatives such as forwards, futures, options, and swaps each offer different advantages and trade-offs. Choosing the right tool requires a good understanding of both the specific needs of the fund and the inherent characteristics of each instrument. The choice for a specific instrument should align with the fund’s overall risk profile and financial strategy.

3. Ongoing Adaptation: The foreign exchange market is dynamic, with rates constantly changing due to various global economic factors. As such, the fund’s hedging strategy should not be static. Regular review and adjustments are essential to ensure that the hedging approach remains aligned with what is happening in FX markets. This dynamic approach can help in managing unforeseen market shifts effectively.

Conclusion

Unfortunately, there is no definitive "yes" or "no" answer. Deciding whether to use FX hedging in a VC fund involves balancing the costs, complexity, and the need to protect against volatility. While each fund's circumstances vary, for many, the additional effort and expense of FX hedging may not be necessary. However, there are likely scenarios where the potential benefits could justify considering it as a worthwhile strategy.

Found this helpful? Sign Up to FundCFO.co to access more articles and templates on reporting, accounting, tax and compliance.